The hired help deserve to skim off $100 million a year?

Glade Sun

October 23, 2009

By Bob Tonachio / Sun contributor The Crossville Chronicle Fri Oct 23, 2009, 11:14 AM CDT

"Nobody who is hired help and who plays with other people's money "deserves" to earn $100 million," gripes the brilliant Steven Pearlstein in an outstanding article for the Washington Post. "That's certainly true in a moral sense. But it is also true economically.... Let's look at the fundamental asymmetry of risk in the investment business. If you were putting your own money at risk," Pearlstein continues, "there's the possibility of making lots more, but there's also the possibility you could lose it all. The same, however, can't be said if you are an investment banker, a hedge fund manager or a trader in credit default swaps. In that case, if you do well, you get a percentage of the winnings or the value of the deal. But if you do poorly and your clients lose money, the worst that happens is that your bonus is zero. You never have to give back anything from the bonus you earned last year. And, you still get a base salary comfortable enough to keep up payments on the Upper East Side townhouse, the summer place on Nantucket and the tuitions at Brearley. "No one cares about over-the-top compensation schemes when business is booming ... and when share prices are rising. But on the downside, everyone cares. During the "Great Bull Market" of the late 1990s, almost no one bothered to question the exorbitant option grants that Silicon Valley companies lavished on their employees (and on their board members!). But once the "Great Bull Market" ended, and the NASDAQ imploded, a new bull market in recrimination and litigation began. Class-action shareholder lawsuits erupted from the smoldering remains of former Wall Street darlings, as desperate shareholders tried to recover some small fraction of their losses. Would it not have been much better for these abused shareholders to sell when the selling was good? Would it not have been better to have raised a skeptical eyebrow toward the questionable corporate practices of the era and headed the other way..., even though questionable corporate practices were producing rising share prices? "Excess compensation in one area leads to excess compensation in others," Pearlstein concludes. "And that, in the end, is how this arms race in executive pay comes about. It's more about envy than economics. The corporate executives complain they should make as much as the investment bankers, the bankers are upset if they don't make as much as the private-equity guys, the private-equity guys demand to make as much as the traders, and the traders won't sit still until they are paid like hedge fund managers.” Excess compensation also leads to sub-optimal shareholder returns. Greed and capital preservation just don't seem to mix very well, especially when the greed belongs to someone else and the capital belongs to you. The big brokerage firms make most of their money by speculating with capital that does not belong to them, or by levying fees and commissions on capital that their clients put at risk in the financial markets. In other words, shareholders and clients bear most of the risks. Yet, whenever any form of success arrives, Wall Street's elite always garner an outsized share of the rewards. That's asymmetry. And in this case, asymmetry might just be another word for "greed."

Bob Tonachio, CEO of Robert James & Associates, Inc., may be contacted at 1-800-530-5700 His firm charges no fees for advice and consultations are always free of charge. Clients, that followed his firm’s recommendations did not suffer losses in the recent bear market.

Text Only

Glade Sun

We the People: You might be a conservative if...
The United States has fared well with the balance of two political viewpoints, Conservatives and Progressives. Conservatives preserve values and practices that have served to make this a stronger country while Progressives embrace new ideas and policies that can improve on what we’ve accomplished so far. In their role, Conservatives protect the best of America when they:

May 22, 2012
Is #5 Alive?
Perhaps you remember the movie “Short Circuit.” There were 5 robots being developed for the military. One of them, #5, was struck by lightning and he came “alive.” After escaping from his military controllers, he developed a gigantic zest for data. It was quite fun to watch him grow and learn to be human.

May 22, 2012 1 Photo
Board of Directors applications available in June
The Fairfield Glade Community Club Election Committee has announced that two (2) Property Owner Director At-Large positions are open for election in 2012.

May 22, 2012
Memorial Day ceremony set Monday at 11 a.m.
The Cumberland County Veterans Council will sponsor a Memorial Day Ceremony May 28 at the Cumberland County Veterans Memorial Park. The ceremony will begin at 11 a.m. with the Cumberland County Band performing, flag/colors presentation, an incredible singer, guest speakers and a special key-note speaker.

May 22, 2012
Read the latest edition of "The Bulletin"
The Crossville Chronicle-Glade Sun also publishes a newsletter called "The Bulletin" in which you'll find a schedule of Glade activities and events, a restaurant and dining guide, golf information, and even tour schedules. Click here for the latest PDF edition of "The Bulletin."

April 21, 2010 1 Link
Commission vacancy to be filled in August election
Commissioners are faced with addressing the issue of a vacant seat on the Cumberland County Commission after the death of one of their own last week.

May 22, 2012
Ladies Club to award 14 scholarships at annual luncheon
It is time! The year-long efforts by members of the Fairfield Glade Ladies Club dedicated to raising funds for Scholarships will come to fruition at the June 6 luncheon meeting.

May 22, 2012
Lions cleared for third annual reverse raffle
The Fairfield Glade Lions Club has received Tennessee State approval for the Third Annual Reverse Raffle drawing. Ticket price remains at $50 and only 500 tickets will be sold again this year. Three great prizes are being offered for the last numbers drawn.

May 22, 2012
Another Day, Another Week: Anticipating red, ripe tomatoes
Here we are in the middle of the month of May already. I can hardly believe how fast the days, weeks, and months speed by on their way to the end of the year.It seems only yesterday that we were shivering in January and hoping for May.

May 22, 2012
Patches of Life: Elevator exercise and staircase mystery
The Renaissance Hotel in downtown Columbus, Ohio, has a very efficient laundry room. The storage room is quite ample also. The employees are extremely friendly. How do we know? We were there. We were attending the graduation ceremony at the Ohio theatre and had reservations at the Renaissance.

May 22, 2012
More Glade Sun Headlines

Glade Sun

Search Results

The hired help deserve to skim off $100 million a year?

Site Map

Contact Us