City frustrated over Caryonah Dam repairs

Area News

November 13, 2009

By Jim Young / jimyoungreporter@gmail.com The Crossville Chronicle Fri Nov 13, 2009, 03:00 PM CST

Crossville City Council members expressed extreme frustration over recent actions by the water quality department of the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC) threatening fines concerning the partial failure of the Caryonah Dam and the city's ongoing efforts to correct the problem.

The discussion came up under the city attorney's report as Ken Chadwell reported to the council about a series of correspondence between the TDEC water quality staff and the city. Chadwell said on the subject of the dam he was concerned about two aspects. The first is what to do with the dam and the second is how to handle the mitigation demands made by TDEC.

Bids for the repair work to fix the dam were scheduled to be opened Thursday after press time. Currently the city has $250,000 budgeted on the project, but also expect the cost could potentially be as much as double that amount. The repair of the dam is under the auspices of the office of safe dams that is a separate branch of TDEC. And this budget amount does not consider the possibility of potential fines for water quality damage.

Shortly after the dam partially failed in August this year the city received a notice of damage to the creek below the dam from so called “fugitive sediment” and requesting the city submit a plan to repair or mitigate the damage. A review of the state law showed that the there was a loophole in the law if the damage was caused by an “unavoidable accident.” Chadwell said that the city had responded to the original notice with that defense in a response letter to TDEC water quality but that office did not even acknowledge that and instead issued a “notice of deficiency” that indicated the city's response was inadequate and fines could follow if a mitigation plan was not submitted.

Chadwell then submitted another response again asserting the unavoidable accident defense but he said the TDEC office was reportedly preparing an assessment of civil penalty, essentially a fine. Chadwell added that such penalties can be quite substantial. He said he would do what the council directed but he offered what he called “practical advice” saying he felt the best action may be to prepare a mitigation plan saying the city would clean up the stream.

While Chadwell said that there have been several attempts by other entities to use the unavoidable accident defense, he added that no one had yet been successful in using that defense.

Crossville Mayor J. H. Graham III commented that the city was caught between to branches of the same agency giving opposing incompatible directions. In the discussion, it was pointed out that currently the city is pumping water out of the lake to keep the level down when it rains and that is continuing to cause sediment.

City engineer Tom Wolf pointed out to the council that any mitigation by the city is basically worthless until the dam is fixed. As water is pumped from the lake to keep pressure off of the dam and protect it from completely failing as required by the safe dams branch of TDEC, the sediment will continue to be a deposited below the dam in Panther Creek.

“We've got two different agencies giving us two different kinds of advice on how to handle this problem,” complained Mayor Graham.

“Lord help us!” commented councilman Boyd Wyatt.

Council members feel they are backed into a corner on the matter and directed city engineer Wolf to work with Chadwell to prepare a mitigation plan outlining removal the sediment from the creek for submission to the water quality office of TDEC. They hope to move forward with the dam repairs and hope to be able to deal with complications.

With all the additional expenses from unexpected projects, council members discussed a possible need for financing some of the cost during the audit committee meeting. City finance director Fred Houston was given instructions to look at expected expenses, grants and other funding and cash balances in city funds. Once Houston has completed his evaluation of the funding, he will report back to the council with recommendations for future action.

While sales taxes remain below levels for the previous several years, the amount is exactly on budget for the reduced amount set in the current city budget.

Text Only

Area News

A champion fair!
Tennessee Department of Agriculture (TDA) Commissioner Julius Johnson recently presented awards to 56 of the state’s top county agricultural fairs. They were recognized with the Merit Award for outstanding achievement during the 2011 fair season. More than 950 people attended the Fairs Merit Awards recognition dinner at the 90th Annual Tennessee Association of Fairs (TAF) convention held January 19-21, in Nashville.

February 3, 2012 2 Photos
Test scores to be reflected in final grades
While student achievement and growth on test scores have begun being used to evaluate teacher performance and to score school districts on effectiveness, those scores have not been reflected on an individual student's report card. That will change with the 2012 Tennessee Comprehensive Assessment Program (TCAP) test when state law will require schools to use those scores as part of a student's final grade.

February 3, 2012
Sneak peek at this year's hottest Super Bowl ads
The Super Bowl is a must-watch TV event, if not for the outcome of the biggest football game of the year, then at least for the multi-million dollar commercials that run throughout. And this year’s buzzworthy spots include celebrity appearances, homages to movies and lots of humor.

February 3, 2012 1 Photo
Counterfeiting draws two-year sentence
A Cumberland County man who was among several local residents charged by Crossville Police with being involved in counterfeiting schemes pleaded guilty last week in Criminal Court and received a two-year prison sentence.

February 3, 2012
Argument over pillows, ashtray, leads to stabbing
A Crossville man suffered a collapsed lung and a woman has been arrested on a felony charge in connection with an incident that took place last week in the city, according to reports.

February 3, 2012
Women charged in theft from employer scheme
Two women were arrested and stolen property recovered after a corporate loss prevention officer uncovered a theft scheme, according to Crossville Police reports.

February 2, 2012
SLIDESHOW: Super Bowl by the numbers The nation's biggest sporting event produces some staggering statistics, from the number of chicken wings consumed -- 1.25 billion -- to the amount of money some people plan to bet on the game.
February 2, 2012
Special blood drive set today
The American Red Cross is reporting lower donations than expected since the start of 2012. O blood types are particularly low, but all blood types are needed.

February 2, 2012
Trio charged with cockfighting in the city
Three young Cumberland County men charged with fighting roosters said they were only sparring their birds, and not holding a cockfight. Doesn't matter, said Crossville Police, who took the trio into custody and formally charged them with what some call a sport now banned in Tennessee.

February 2, 2012
Residents say 'No Dump'
Residents of the Crab Orchard community told their city council members a landfill isn't welcome in their community at a public hearing last week. Others expressed concern that a landfill would not spur the type of development they envision for the small town east of Crossville.

February 2, 2012 2 Photos
More Area News Headlines

Area News

Search Results

City frustrated over Caryonah Dam repairs

Site Map

Contact Us