A Crossville Police Officer was correct in stopping a suspected drunk driver, based on information that he had received and after observing the motorist, the Tennessee Criminal Court of Appeals has ruled, and as a result, Frank Edward Davidson of Cumberland County will now face trial for tenth offense driving under the influence, second offense driving on a revoked license and driving with a restriction.
Davidson was indicted by the Cumberland County Grand Jury on May 8, 2007, on the listed charges after Crossville Police Lt. Tony Davis arrested him. Davis testified during a suppression hearing that he had received through his dispatcher a complaint that Davidson may have been intoxicated after being observed by citizens falling in a bar parking lot and traveling through a drive-thru at the Tobacco Store at the intersection of Lantana Rd. and West Ave.
Davis testified that he followed Davidson's vehicle to Elmore Rd. and then onto Hwy. 70 N as it reached the city limits where he then conducted a traffic stop.
While having Davidson's vehicle under observation, Davis testified that Davidson drove left of the center line four times.
A poorly lighted video from the patrol car's video camera was inconclusive and Criminal Court Judge Leon Burns ruled in favor of Assistant Public Defender Cynthia Lyons' motion that there was not probable cause of reasonable suspicion for Davis to stop the motorist.
In his ruling, Judge Burns questioned whether it was reasonable to expect a motorist to stay within his lane of traffic at all times. " ... touching of the line is something that I suspect that we all do from time to time," Burns said when issuing his ruling.
Burns admitted that "it is a close case," but he said evidence told him that the traffic stop was conducted more on the citizen complaint and less on "seeing bad driving."
The trial judge concluded, "This is a horrible case, and a pretty serious case with which he's been charged: a multiple offense DUI, and violation of the habitual offender order. And (Davidson) is no stranger to the system.
"And I suspect, if your picture is not on the wall down there to be aware that (Davidson) has no license to drive, it ought to be on the wall down there.
"But, under the ... what have seen, I don't think that there's enough reasonable suspicion to stop in this case ... "
The 13th Judicial District Attorney General's Office and Assistant DA Holly Hunter filed an appeal of the ruling and wrote that the totality of the circumstances were considered, including the officer's personal observations and rational inferences and deductions of the trained law enforcement officer.
The court added that this also includes information from citizens and the pattern of operation of certain offenders.
The appeals court did agree with Judge Burns that the case was a close call on the issue of the legality of the stop.
The District Attorney's Office stated Friday it was prepared to go to trial now that the Appeals Court has made its ruling. Davidson's case is now on the deadline docket that will be called Wednesday.
Area News
Appeals court overturns ruling in 10th DUI case
Defendant now faces trial
- Area News
-
-
Plane has rough landing
No one was injured when a pilot veered off a runway to avoid a deer that was in the path of his light airplane as he landed the craft.
-
Lemert grave site rededication set Monday
The restoration of the gravesite of 1st Sgt. Milo Lemert, Cumberland County's only WWI Medal of Honor recipient, is finally complete after months of repair and rebuilding. A special dedication will be held May 28 at the City Cemetery at Sgt. Lemert's gravesite. The dedication will immediately follow the 11 a.m. annual Memorial Day Ceremony for Cumberland County in downtown Crossville. The public is invited to both events.
-
County to use new district boundaries to fill vacancy
The Cumberland County Commission approved a resolution to use new district boundary lines in the August County General Election in order to fill the vacancy created by the death of 9th District Commissioner Clyde Cramer.
-
THP to enforce seat belt usage this Memorial Day weekend
The Tennessee Highway Patrol is planning to step up efforts to enforce seat belt usage over the Memorial Day holiday weekend. State Troopers along with other state and local law enforcement agencies are participating in the national seat belt enforcement campaign, Click it or Ticket, May 21 through June 3.
-
Shooting victim identified; accomplice jailed
A burglar who fled from a home invasion after his partner was shot by a resident may be held responsible for his friend's death, sources close to the investigation of Tuesday's fatal shooting have told the Chronicle.
-
Healthy eating, activity earn CO honors
Students at Crab Orchard Elementary have been eating better and getting more activity during the past school year. Those efforts have been recognized with prestigious awards for school health.
-
Defendant pleads guilty to avoid jail
A Crossville area man told a Criminal Court judge earlier this month he was entering a plea of guilty to fraud to keep from going to jail.
-
Man sentenced in sexual battery, statutory rape cases
A Crossville man charged with raping one woman and with having sexual relations with an underaged teen in a separate incident has pleaded guilty to related charges and was sentenced to jail.
-
County to build, operate Big South Fork Visitor's Center
The Big South Fork Visitor's Center may become a reality after the county commission narrowly approved building and operating the facility once the project is completed.
-
One dead in shooting near PH
One person is dead, a homeowner slightly injured, and at least a third person is in custody following a fatal shooting that may have been sparked by a home invasion near the Pleasant Hill community. And a fourth person might be connected with the incident.
- More Area News Headlines
-
Plane has rough landing
NJ Man Charged With Murder in Death of Patz
Support, Fun for Kids of Fallen Soldiers at Camp
Fugitive Penguin Caught, Returned to Aquarium
50 Years Later, Underground Fire Still Burning
Light Show Transforms Sydney Opera House
Raw Video: Unruly Passenger Restrained in Miami
Raw Video: Robber Uses Drive-thru Window
Raw Video: Dragon Arrives at Space Station
Calif.'s Coronado Named Nation's Best Beach
CEO Salaries Become Sore Issue in Labor Disputes
Raw Video: Fight Erupts in Ukrainian Parliament
Texan Ranchers Remain Wary of Drought
Raw Video: Soldiers Plant Flags at Arlington
Police: Man Arrested in Etan Patz Disappearance
NYC Protests: the Revolution Will Be Scripted
Chicago U.S. Attorney Fitzgerald Resigns
Neighbors of Etan Patz's Suspect: It's Shocking
Gulf Fishermen Reel From Seafood Troubles
Stuntman Makes Skydive Without Parachute in UK
Raw Video: Bride Who Faked Cancer Released
